Карточка игры / ROGUE BY ROGUEMonster Train
Оригинальный текст · АнглийскийMonster Train is a strategic roguelike deck building game with a twist. Set on a train to hell, you’ll use tactical decision making to defend multiple vertical battlegrounds. With real time competitive multiplayer and endless replayability, Monster Train is always on time.
Почему такая оценка?
Оригинальный текст · Упрощённый китайский
把布阵和卡组发展结合得很紧密，路线规划足以影响胜负；主要局限在敌人变化和高难度下的策略收缩。
Основной игровой процесс
Вес 25 %9,0 / 10Оригинальный текст · Упрощённый китайский
三层布阵把出牌时机、承伤和上楼敌人联系起来，短局能较快形成决策循环；同时处理多层对新手有负担。
Сборки и стратегия
Вес 25 %9,0 / 10Оригинальный текст · Упрощённый китайский
主副氏族、英雄、卡牌改造和复制产生相互制约的选择；高契约下部分路线被极端数值压缩，因此未给满分。
Реиграбельность
Вес 20 %8,5 / 10Оригинальный текст · Упрощённый китайский
氏族机制、英雄和变异条件会改变解题方式，难度阶梯持续提出新要求；敌人与首领池偏小限制遭遇的新鲜度。
Случайность и справедливость
Вес 20 %8,0 / 10Оригинальный текст · Упрощённый китайский
首领信息预告允许提前针对，路线和卡牌升级能缓解抽牌运气；最高难度对强组合的依赖使容错下降。
Качество исполнения и удобство
Вес 10 %7,5 / 10Оригинальный текст · Упрощённый китайский
波次计数、首领预览和对局记录改善信息表达；多层盘面仍有学习负担，快照包含片头导致启动挂起的报告。
- Автор обзора
Оригинальный текст · Упрощённый китайский
Rogue by Rogue · AI 资料评测- Оценённая версия
Оригинальный текст · Упрощённый китайский
具体构建未知；以所引资料描述的版本为准
Область оценки и ограничения
Оригинальный текст · Упрощённый китайский
未进行试玩；分数是依据已收录评述与社区具体反馈作出的主观资料评测。旧反馈跨版本、部分原始材料为不可重开的本地快照；本次 Steam 核查仅确认玩法与功能，未复测平衡、性能或报告的故障是否仍存在。
Источники обзора 02
- 01Архивные материалыОткрыть архив внешних материалов ↓
Оригинальный текст · Упрощённый китайский
收录评论与社区资料（2026-10-01 快照）
使用 作者观点摘要 的 Tier list Part 1 (2023) 的具体优缺点，以及 玩家好评、玩家批评 与 资料核查说明；不使用旧等级、外部分数或销量反推。
- 02Интернет-источникОткрыть оригинал ↗
Оригинальный текст · Упрощённый китайский
Monster Train · Steam 官方商店
2026-10-08 访问。Steam 商店核对三层战场、双氏族、卡牌改造复制、契约难度与首领预览。未据商店介绍推定性能或故障已修复。
Видеообзоры
Обзоры и разборы на YouTube и Bilibili на любых языках. Откройте оригинал, чтобы посмотреть видео.
Другие мнения для справки.
Архивные сторонние обзоры и материалы сообщества могут относиться к разным версиям. Внешние мнения и оценки представлены отдельно. Полный контекст доступен в исходных видео.
Обсуждения игроков
Оригинальный текст · АнглийскийA 2020 roguelike deckbuilder from Shiny Shoe in which you defend a multi-floor demon train's pyre from angel invaders by placing units on vertical floors, pairing two clans per run.
Оригинальный текст · АнглийскийMonster Train is broadly regarded as one of the best roguelike deckbuilders after Slay the Spire. Steam shows about 96% positive across roughly 23k reviews (Overwhelmingly Positive), Metacritic critic score is 86 from 27 reviews (all positive), and the Metacritic user score is 7.9 (lower and more mixed than Steam). Critics and players praise the floor-placement tactics, clan mixing and snowball-into-broken-combo runs. Criticism centres on the small enemy/boss roster, a long unlock grind, balance at top Covenant ranks, and dated art. It is not early access; it has had free content updates and a paid DLC (The Last Divinity), and since 2025 many reviewers steer newcomers to Monster Train 2 instead.
Что хвалят игроки
- Оригинальный текст · АнглийскийMulti-floor train layout adds spatial tactics (what goes on which floor, floor-wide effects, hit-point math) that Slay the Spire lacks; critics called it its own kind of puzzle
- Оригинальный текст · АнглийскийPairing a main clan with a secondary clan produces many synergy combinations and encourages experimentation
- Оригинальный текст · АнглийскийEach clan has a distinct signature mechanic, which keeps runs feeling different
- Оригинальный текст · АнглийскийSnowballing into an over-the-top 'exodia' deck and steamrolling enemies is deeply satisfying; some players say it feels more empowering than Slay the Spire
- Оригинальный текст · АнглийскийBoss challenges are telegraphed up front, so you can draft toward them; several reviewers like this clarity
- Оригинальный текст · АнглийскийRuns are fairly short and playable in bursts; the game is accessible to genre newcomers and ramps up via the Covenant difficulty system
- Оригинальный текст · АнглийскийUpbeat soundtrack, and strong replay value (players report hundreds of hours and 100% achievements)
- Оригинальный текст · АнглийскийSteady free updates added champions, mutators, run records and Steam Workshop mod support
Что критикуют игроки
- Оригинальный текст · АнглийскийVery small enemy and boss variety: players say you see essentially every enemy within a single run, and encounters feel like repetitive bullet sponges
- Оригинальный текст · АнглийскийRuns are short and deckbuilding feels cut off just as it gets interesting; only about 10 fights per run compared with dozens in Slay the Spire
- Оригинальный текст · АнглийскийHigh Covenant ranks (around 20-25) scale enemies so aggressively that many cards and some clan pairings become unviable, forcing the same 'broken' combos
- Оригинальный текст · АнглийскийSome complain drafted cards are not much better than starters, or that picks are obvious, so choices feel less meaningful
- Оригинальный текст · АнглийскийArt style and animation are polarising: several call it mobile-game or Hearthstone-like, cheap looking or ugly
- Оригинальный текст · АнглийскийReported crashes or hangs on startup linked to the intro video (AVProVideo/Unity errors) that some say persist years later
- Оригинальный текст · АнглийскийWith Monster Train 2 containing the first game's clans and more, a number of recent negative reviews say not to buy the original at $25
Отличительные особенности
- Оригинальный текст · АнглийскийVertical multi-floor battlefield with a pyre you must protect, mixing deckbuilding with tower-defence-style positioning
- Оригинальный текст · АнглийскийTwo-clan deck construction (main plus allied clan) with a champion choice defining the strategy
- Оригинальный текст · АнглийскийUnits persist and level up across fights via upgrades, making the deck feel like an army that grows stronger
- Оригинальный текст · АнглийскийCovenant ladder, with a campaign structure where bosses are known in advance and players draft toward them
- Оригинальный текст · АнглийскийPlaying the demons defending hell against angels gives it a goofier, lighter tone than Slay the Spire; one reviewer calls it Slay the Spire's chiller, goofier cousin
- Оригинальный текст · АнглийскийCompetitive PvP multiplayer mode, unusual for the genre, and later Steam Workshop mod support
Спорные моменты
- Оригинальный текст · АнглийскийVersus Slay the Spire: many say Monster Train is deeper and more empowering, while others find it less tightly balanced and more luck-dependent or 'braindead'
- Оригинальный текст · АнглийскийDifficulty: some call it much easier than Slay the Spire and relaxing, others call high Covenants punishing and unfun
- Оригинальный текст · АнглийскийArt direction and music: praised as slick and upbeat by some, called dated, ugly or only serviceable by others
- Оригинальный текст · АнглийскийWhether to buy the original or go straight to Monster Train 2, which many see as strictly better for the same price
Повторы и неудобства
- Оригинальный текст · АнглийскийUnlocking all clans, cards and Covenant levels means replaying the same handful of stages many times, and some reviewers describe it as more grind than strategy
- Оригинальный текст · АнглийскийLow Covenant ranks are seen as too easy, and reaching meaningful difficulty takes 15-20 runs
- Оригинальный текст · АнглийскийLate-game balance feels restrictive: players can sense at the start of a run whether it is doomed, and failing is less fun than in Slay the Spire
- Оригинальный текст · АнглийскийRepetitive encounters and bloated card mechanics make runs feel samey after the first dozens of hours
- Оригинальный текст · АнглийскийWeak narrative, so there is little story motivation between runs
- Оригинальный текст · АнглийскийDrafted cards often feel only marginally better than the starter cards, so some players feel drafting choices matter little and the meta-progression is outrageously long
Ожидаемые улучшения
- Оригинальный текст · АнглийскийAdd more enemy types and bosses (Metacritic users and critics such as Softpedia asked for more boss variety)
- Оригинальный текст · АнглийскийFine-tune Covenant scaling and clan balance at the top ranks so more cards and clan combinations stay viable
- Оригинальный текст · АнглийскийReduce or streamline the unlock grind, since factions and content are gated behind repeated runs of the same short campaign
- Оригинальный текст · АнглийскийGive players more ways to reduce variance (starting-hand or loadout options) rather than rerolling setups
- Оригинальный текст · АнглийскийLengthen or deepen the drafting phase so deck building feels less rushed
- Оригинальный текст · АнглийскийFix the persistent startup crash and improve Steam Deck and other platform stability
Оригинальный текст · АнглийскийLaunched May 2020 to strong reviews (IGN 9/10, Game Informer 9/10, Rock Paper Shotgun called it possibly the best deckbuilder since Slay the Spire; Northernlion dubbed it 2020's best deckbuilder) and was nominated for IGN Best Strategy/Tactics and a D.I.C.E. strategy/simulation award. Ported to Xbox One (Dec 2020), Switch (Aug 2021, later the First Class complete edition), iOS (Oct 2022) and PS5 (July 2024). Post-launch free updates include Friends & Foes (champions, bosses, run records), Wild Mutations (35 mutators) and Herzal's Workshop (Steam Workshop mods); paid DLC is The Last Divinity. Steam's all-time rating stays around 96% but the recent 30-day sample was 88% (small sample), partly reflecting negative reviews urging buyers toward Monster Train 2 (released May 21, 2025). Steam shows Windows only. Revenue estimate is approximate: steam-revenue-calculator.com estimates about $23.6M gross and $7.0M net on Steam (Boxleiter-style estimate, not audited), and SteamSpy lists 500k-1M owners. OpenCritic could not be retrieved (search budget exhausted and the page was not located), so opencritic is null.
Источники сообщества
- Оригинальный текст · АнглийскийTop helpful positive and negative English Steam reviews (local file) ↗
- Оригинальный текст · АнглийскийLocal Steam metadata: review counts, SteamSpy owners, Metacritic 86, revenue estimate ↗
- Оригинальный текст · АнглийскийSteam store page: review summary, DLC, critic quotes, update list ↗
- Оригинальный текст · АнглийскийMetacritic Metascore 86, 27 critic reviews, user score 7.9, outlet snippets ↗
- Оригинальный текст · АнглийскийMetacritic user review themes: limited enemies, easy low Covenants, weak narrative ↗
- Оригинальный текст · АнглийскийWikipedia: IGN 9/10, Screen Rant 4/5, awards nominations, platforms and release dates ↗
- Оригинальный текст · АнглийскийSteam community discussion themes: crashes, balance, DLC bugs, localization ↗
- Оригинальный текст · АнглийскийEstimated gross/net revenue (approximate, Boxleiter method) ↗
Архив мнений автора 1
Сторонние пересказы на основе автоматических субтитров могут содержать ошибки расшифровки или интерпретации.
Оригинальный текст · АнглийскийTier list Part 1 (2023)
Оригинальный текст · АнглийскийMonster Train is a deck-building roguelike set on a three-floor train, where you manage three separate boards at once. He calls the gameplay amazing, with one of the largest pools of possible builds thanks to faction and champion choices. He admits it can overwhelm people new to deck builders and that it is challenging. He has played it a lot, loves the art and soundtrack, and ranks it high A, possibly S.
Что хвалит автор
- Оригинальный текст · АнглийскийHuge variety of builds and decks, possibly the biggest roster of builds in the genre
- Оригинальный текст · АнглийскийPick a main faction with its own champion (two per faction), then a secondary faction, so every run starts differently
- Оригинальный текст · АнглийскийReplayability: he says it never gets old
- Оригинальный текст · АнглийскийChallenging gameplay
- Оригинальный текст · АнглийскийPhenomenal art style
- Оригинальный текст · АнглийскийGreat soundtrack
Проблемы, отмеченные автором
- Оригинальный текст · АнглийскийManaging three levels at once can feel overwhelming, especially for newcomers to deck builders
- Оригинальный текст · АнглийскийNot suited to people who don't know deck-building games
- Оригинальный текст · АнглийскийAnimations are pretty basic (he corrects himself to say the art style is what shines)
Наблюдения о дизайне
- Оригинальный текст · АнглийскийThe three-level train means you manage three boards simultaneously, placing minions on different floors
- Оригинальный текст · АнглийскийMain plus secondary faction pairing changes the run completely from the start
